Thursday 17 July 2014

Relief Reads 17 - The Shipping News

The Shipping News by Annie Proulx

Charity Shop: The Cyrenians, Eldon Square, Newcastle

Charity: The Cyrenians is now Changing Lives. Changing Lives provides specialist support services for thousands of vulnerable people and their families. They work with people experiencing homelessness, addiction and a range of other problems.

Price: £0.50

Book Blurb: Quoyle is a hapless, hopeless hack journalist living and working in  New York. When his no-good wife is killed in a spectacular road accident, Quoyle heads for the land of his forefathers - the remotest corner of far-flung Newfoundland. With his delinquent daughters, Bunny and Sunshine in tow, Quoyle finds hinself a part of an unfolding, exhilarating Atlantic drama. THE SHIPPING NEWS is an irresistable comedy of human life and possibility.

Expectation: A comedic story of a city-dweller adapting to rural life.

Reality: It was a strange book, that I wouldn't call a comedy. Set amongst a back drop of grief, sexual abuse and murder the book follows the life of Quoyle as he floats unhappily through life until his aunt encourages him to move with his two daughters to Newfoundland following the death of his wife in a car crash (after she had just sold their children ?!) Life in Newfoundland suits him, and supported by his aunt, new friends and colleagues Quoyle begins to stand on his own two feet and find out more about his (sometimes quite dark) family history. The story borders on the supernatural at time, although most odd occurrences are explained logically, but not all. It's written in an odd way, very jumpy and rarely has full sentences. This probably is trying to convey how Quoyle's mind works but it took me a while to adjust to.

Overall Rating
It was a struggle           2        3        4        5        6        7        8       9      Gripping page  
to make it                                                                                                        turner

It lost some points because the blurb lied, it's not a comedy. It is odd, but not terrible. Overall it's not a waste of time to read this book and I wouldn't mind watching the film if that opportunity ever arose.

Twist Scale:
Knew the beginning,                                                                                 As twisty as the 
middle and end         2       3        4         5       6        7        8        9      bendy wendy road
from the first line 

There were child slavery, crashes, murders, sexual abuse, drowning, houses disappearing and supernatural occurences. Some were surprise, some were hinted at prior to their occurence. Not the most straightforward plot in the world!



Tear-jerker Scale:
 As dry as a house       2        3       4         5         6         7       8        9     Cried an ocean
 throughout

Most events were so incredulous little empathy was generated. However I did feel some sadness at times from the Aunt's life.

Main Character(s): Quoyle - see 'reality' above. Quoyle's aunt is a key and complex character, who's lived through alot. We get her perspective on events too. Her motives are unclear, she is trying to block the past out of her life yet returns to her childhood home...?

Moral of the Story: I'm not sure. Be wary of being blinded by love.


***

Coming up: Call the Midwife by Jennifer Worth

Tuesday 15 July 2014

Relief Reads 16 - From Notting Hill with Love... Actually

From Notting Hill with love... Actually by Ali McNamara

Charity Shop: Cancer Research UK, Hexham

Charity: See earlier posts

Price: £1.75

Book Blurb: Scarlett loves the movies. But does she love sensible fiance David just as much? With a big white wedding on the horizon, Scarlett really should have decided by now... // When she has the chance to house-sit in Notting Hill - the setting of one of her favourite movies - Scarlett jumps at the chance. But living life like a movie is trickier than it seems, especially when her new neighbour Sean is so irritating. And so irritatingly handsome, too. // Scarlett soon finds herself starring in a romantic comedy of her very own: but who will end up as the leading man?

Expectation: A ridiculous rom-com

Reality: See my comments below. It was passable but was just a trashy romcom.

Overall Rating
It was a struggle           2        3        4        5        6        7        8       9      Gripping page  
to make it                                                                                                        turner

It was passable. This girl is trying to prove to the world that life can be like the movies, which it isn't, but then the book makes out that it is. The storyline is so unbelievable which would be fine in a romcom but because it's a romcom about romcoms it grated on me. All in all though it was a light-hearted story and I did enjoy it except the ending. There was a nice underlying storyline about finding her mother which did move it a bit beyond the sickeningly superficial veneer.

Twist Scale:
Knew the beginning,                                                                                 As twisty as the 
middle and end         2       3        4         5       6        7        8        9      bendy wendy road
from the first line 

It was ridiculous, so the twists weren't much of a surprise.



Tear-jerker Scale:
 As dry as a house       2        3       4         5         6         7       8        9     Cried an ocean
 throughout

As I said, light hearted.

Main Character(s): Scarlett, soon to be engaged who works at her Dad's popcorn machine company. Taking a break from the real world to 'find herself' by housesitting in Notting Hill. She's self absorbed and doesn't have much of a clue about consequences. She just floats along through life letting things happen to her and will continue to do so by the looks of thing

Moral of the Story: I hope it wasn't supposed to have a moral!


***

Coming up: The Shipping News by Annie Proulx (I thought it was called the shipping forecast... But then got confused because it's set in Newfoundland not the North Sea, but then it's the shipping News which makes a lot more sense)